As a child in the 1970s, I spent an embarrassing amount of time studying an insert in the Sunday newspaper from Columbia House. It featured dozens of tiny sheets of stamps, each displaying the cover of a popular album. The deal was irresistible: Attach a penny, lick a few stamps, stick them on an order card and receive a handful of records or tapes for practically nothing.
There was, of course, a catch. I had to agree to purchase a certain number of additional records or tapes at full price, plus shipping. My brothers warned me to stay away. Apparently, they understood contracts better than I did. So, I never joined the club, but I sure licked a lot of those stamps.
Even at that young age, I wondered whether a company could legally hold a minor to such an agreement. Generally, contracts with minors are unenforceable, but that didn’t stop Columbia House from aggressively marketing its offers to young music lovers. By 1975, the Columbia Record and Tape Club had more than 3 million members. That’s a lot of teenagers with questionable financial judgment.
How we listen to music has changed dramatically since then, and Columbia House tried to keep up. It moved from vinyl albums to reel-to-reel tapes, 8-tracks, cassettes and CDs. The company changed hands several times and eventually expanded into DVDs and Blu-rays. But its controversial business model, known as negative-option billing, continued to haunt it.
Negative-option billing is a practice in which consumers receive goods or services unless they actively decline them, often resulting in unexpected charges. Sound familiar? Today, we call many of these arrangements subscriptions. The difference is that Columbia House made its money shipping music through the mail, while today’s companies can charge our credit cards every month without anyone having to lick a stamp.
When I was in college in the late 1980s, another creative approach to the Columbia House business model was making the rounds. Many college students had campus mailboxes, including some that were rarely used. The story was that a fictitious name, an unused mailbox and a little help from someone in the mailroom could produce a shipment of those introductory CDs without anyone being accountable for the purchases expected later. I heard about this from others, naturally. I would never have participated in anything that might be considered mail fraud. Besides, I was too busy studying. At least that is my story.
After years of ownership changes, financial struggles, a security breach and competition from online retailers, Columbia House eventually disappeared as we knew it. A 2015 revival attempted to capitalize on the vinyl-record resurgence with a subscription service, but competing with music streaming was a tough assignment.
Today, I can listen to virtually any song ever recorded with a few instructions to Alexa. I don’t have to wait for the mailman, find a place to store another stack of albums or worry about accidentally ordering 12 CDs I never wanted.
And yet, I miss those little stamps. Maybe it was the excitement of circling an album, imagining the music inside and believing I had discovered the greatest deal in the history of commerce. Or maybe it was the simple joy of getting something for a penny.
Decades later, I still remember those stamps. I suppose that is proof that even when you avoid a bad deal, the advertising can stick with you. And unlike those stamps, that memory has never required another penny.
Have a teriffic Tuesday and thanks for reading.
Shane Goodman
Editor and Publisher
Times Vedette digital newsletter
shane@gctimesnews.com
641-332-2707
